top of page
Search

Disclosure Alone Is Not The Same As Understanding

Updated: Feb 8

Disclosure Alone Is Not the Same as Understanding In recent years, conversations around HOA management relationships have increasingly centered on one word: Disclosure. If something is disclosed, the assumption is that the issue has been addressed. But disclosure alone does not automatically create transparency — or understanding. Most HOA board members are volunteers. They are often asked to review lengthy agreements that reference banking relationships, affiliated vendors, insurance arrangements, or technology programs using language that is technically compliant but difficult to interpret. Even when a financial relationship is mentioned somewhere in a contract, several critical questions often remain: What does the arrangement actually mean in practice? Who benefits financially? How much value is being generated? Does the incentive structure align with the association’s best interest? Would a typical homeowner reasonably understand the impact? Disclosure without clarity can create a false sense of comfort. The goal should not simply be to “check the disclosure box.” The goal should be informed consent — where board members fully understand the financial relationships connected to their community and can evaluate whether those relationships are appropriate. Why This Conversation Is Not Unique to the U.S. This challenge is not limited to one country or one management model. Strata management professionals in other regions have also raised concerns about how disclosure alone can fall short of true transparency. For additional perspective, Dr. Nicole Johnston discusses pervasive conflicts of interest and the limitations of disclosure in strata management in this webinar: https://youtu.be/m8KTTu2MfA0?si=RaFbySNJHdH8cUxD Her discussion highlights a universal governance issue: When financial relationships are technically disclosed but not clearly understood, decision-makers cannot fully evaluate risk. Closing the Information Gap CASA Alliance exists to help close that gap. Our goal is not to create conflict, but to provide practical tools that help boards move beyond surface-level disclosures and begin asking clear, written questions about: Banking arrangements Vendor programs Insurance compensation structures Affiliated business relationships One starting point is the HOA Management Conflict of Interest Disclosure Form, designed to translate complex practices into plain language so boards can make informed decisions. You can access it here: https://www.casaalliance.org/category/all-products Transparency Requires Understanding Transparency is not achieved when something is merely mentioned in a contract. Transparency exists when the people responsible for governance clearly understand: How money flows Who benefits And whether those incentives align with the community’s best interests If you are a board member, homeowner, manager, or industry professional who believes governance should be built on clarity — not assumptions — we invite you to continue the conversation. Sunlight strengthens trust.
What happens when financial relationships are technically disclosed - but no one actually understands them? If they're disclosed at all.

In recent years, conversations around HOA management relationships have increasingly centered on one word:


Disclosure.


If something is disclosed, the assumption is that the issue has been addressed.

But disclosure alone does not automatically create transparency - or understanding.


Most HOA board members are volunteers. They are often asked to review lengthy agreements that reference banking relationships, affiliated vendors, insurance arrangements, or technology programs using language that is technically compliant but difficult to interpret.


Even when a financial relationship is mentioned somewhere in a contract, several critical questions often remain:


  • What does the arrangement actually mean in practice?

  • Who benefits financially?

  • How much value is being generated?

  • Does the incentive structure align with the association’s best interest?

  • Would a typical homeowner reasonably understand the impact?


Disclosure without clarity can create a false sense of comfort.


The goal should not simply be to “check the disclosure box.”


The goal should be informed consent - where board members fully understand the financial relationships connected to their community and can evaluate whether those relationships are appropriate. If a management company can derive income off of your account, then why can't the bank pay those credits directly to the association or provide a higher interest rate?


Why This Conversation Is Not Unique to the U.S.


This challenge is not limited to one country or one management model.

Strata management professionals in other regions have also raised concerns about how disclosure alone can fall short of true transparency.

For additional perspective, Dr. Nicole Johnston discusses pervasive conflicts of interest and the limitations of disclosure in strata management in this webinar:





Her discussion highlights, amongst other important topics, a universal governance issue:


When financial relationships are technically disclosed but not clearly understood, decision-makers cannot fully evaluate risk.


Closing the Information Gap


CASA Alliance exists to help close that gap.


Our goal is not to create conflict, but to provide practical tools that help boards move beyond surface-level disclosures and begin asking clear, written questions about:


  • Banking arrangements

  • Vendor programs

  • Insurance compensation structures

  • Affiliated business relationships


One starting point is the HOA Management Conflict of Interest Disclosure Form, designed to translate complex practices into plain language so boards can make informed decisions.


You can access it here:





Transparency Requires Understanding


Transparency is not achieved when something is merely mentioned in a contract.

Transparency exists when the people responsible for governance clearly understand:


  • How money flows

  • Who benefits

  • And whether those incentives align with the community’s best interests


If you are a board member, homeowner, manager, or industry professional who believes governance should be built on clarity - not assumptions - we invite you to continue the conversation.


Sunlight strengthens trust.


Comments

bottom of page